A prayer for your scrutiny committee
|
Hello, here is a prayer for your scrutiny committee, in case you find it useful. --------------------- As we sit down around this committee table May we be the best version of our scrutiny selves May we work together with respect and compassion And always remember the citizens we seek to serve As we steady ourselves for our scrutiny work May we feel confident about the tasks before us May we feel well prepared And ready to challenge constructively As we start our first item May we be sure of our purpose May we be guided well by our chair And focussed on making a difference As we greet our first witness May we see them calm and relaxed Knowing why they are here and what to expect And open to dialogue as we are open to dialogue As we ask our first questions May we show we are respectful by our words May we show we are listening by our faces And see thought in the faces of those who we talk with As we conclude each item May we be clear about our conclusions May our recommendations be impactful And let us be happy with our agreed next steps As we end our our meeting Let us feel we have used our time well Let us reflect on what we have done And look forward to when we next meet If we should look back in three months time May we be grateful for the assurance we have provided May we be grateful for the improvements we have helped with And pleased to have played our part Amen If you would like to see / add any comments, I have posted this prayer on LinkedIn here. |
Dear scrutineer,
Get reflections like this straight to your inbox. I also share them on LinkedIn.
“What’s the best structure for scrutiny? And why is it the single committee system?” This is what Chairperson Alex said to me last week and, although she was half joking, I think I agree with her. So, if you are looking to review your scrutiny arrangements, involved in creating a new council or just wondering if your structure is the right one, see if my thinking stacks up for you. I’d say, the single committee system is best for scrutiny because: It’s more strategic. A single committee gets...
How does scrutiny actually make a difference? What are the exact mechanisms through which scrutiny influences the executive? It’s a tricky topic but here are ten suggestions. See if they ring true for you. I’m looking at this from a realist perspective. This is an approach that encourages us to identify the social mechanisms that might explain how a particular programme might achieve its outcomes. Take the example of CCTV in car parks, discussed by Pawson and Tilley in their book Realistic...
Dear scrutineer, see what you think about this scenario. It’s the end of the item on the transport strategy and Vice Chair Jo is inviting the scrutiny committee to agree some conclusions and recommendations. Councillor Lewis has his hand up.“Can we recommend that we have a briefing note on the active travel plan, please?” There is the briefest hint of a frown on Jo’s face, but she catches it before anyone notices. “Yes, we can certainly put that in the mix, Councillor Lewis.” She’s conflicted...